Name: Malibu Butterscotch Schnapps Cocktail
Prep time: 10 min
Total time: 10 min
Ingredients: 2 ounces butterscotch schnapps; 3 ounces Malibu rum, or rum of choice; 4 ounces whole milk, half and half, or coconut milk would all work, you can use any creamer of choice though. A vanilla creamer is delicious in this cocktail. I suggest plain or vanilla creamer. Start with a smaller amount of the milk of choice, then add if you want your cocktail creamier.; 1 -2 tablespoons crushed butterscotch hard candies, you can use sugar free too; 1 - 2 tablespoons butterscotch syrup, or sugar free butterscotch syrup, both of these are optional for a bigger boost of butterscotch flavor; Melted white chocolate or vanilla frosting, I used frosting from the small tubs found in the baking aisle at your local grocery stores, supermarket, Target, and Walmart stores.

Jump to Recipe

This delicious Malibu Butterscotch Schnapps Cocktail is a rich creamy cocktail made with rum, butterscotch schnapps, and crushed butterscotch candy. It’s such a fabulous cocktail!

If you’re looking for a fun, festive and oh so delicious cocktail that is just right for any holiday or occasion, I can help you with this delicious, creamy cocktail that’s the perfect addition to any gathering or intimate evening for two, because, this cocktail will fit the bill. It’s a simple cocktail that I can make quickly and hand out to guests at my parties or at a holiday meal. It’s a great adult beverage to celebrate the holidays and so special when celebrating an anniversary and Valentine’s Day. and once you make it, I think you’ll agree.

Malibu Butterscotch Rum Cocktail

This cocktail has all the hallmark flavors of butterscotch schnapps, coconut rum, creamy half and half, and crushed butterscotch candies and are shaken together to create a cocktail that I pour into a glass rimmed with white fluffy frosting or melted, creamy white chocolate that’s been coated in crushed butterscotch candy for a fun, festive and yet elegant look. It’s a show-stopper that’s as beautiful as it is delicious!

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

It only takes a handful of simple ingredients to make.
It’s an easy cocktail that’s ready in just a few minutes.
It is a beautiful looking cocktail that has a touch of elegance.
The flavors of butterscotch and rum make a classic taste sensation in your mouth.

Ingredients for Two Cocktails

You’ll only need a few ingredients to make this cocktail and the decorative rimming around the glass which you can find them all quickly and easily at your local grocery store, supermarkets, along with Target and Walmart. This cocktail may look fancy, but the ingredients certainly aren’t.

For the Cocktail

2 ounces butterscotch schnapps
3 ounces Malibu rum, or rum of choice
4 ounces whole milk, half and half, or coconut milk would all work, you can use any creamer of choice though. A vanilla creamer is delicious in this cocktail. I suggest plain or vanilla creamer. Start with a smaller amount of the milk of choice, then add if you want your cocktail creamier.
1 tablespoon crushed butterscotch hard candies, you can use sugar free too
1 to 2 tablespoons butterscotch syrup, or sugar free butterscotch syrup, both of these are optional for a bigger boost of butterscotch flavor

For the Decorative Rim

Melted white chocolate or vanilla frosting, I used frosting from the small tubs found in the baking aisle at your local grocery stores, supermarket, Target, and Walmart stores.
Crushed butterscotch candies, regular or sugar free

How to Make a Malibu Butterscotch Rum Cocktail

Making this creamy, luscious cocktail only takes a few minutes and very little effort. You’ll be in and out of the kitchen or your home bar with two drinks in hand in no time flat!

Dip the rim of two cocktail glasses into melted white chocolate or vanilla frosting.
Roll the dipped rims in a shallow dish with crushed butterscotch candy.
Fill a large cocktail shaker with ice and the cocktail ingredients.
Shake vigorously, then pour into the prepared glasses. Now, enjoy!

Substitutions and Variations

You can use whole milk or half and half. You can even use a small amount of heavy cream.
You can use coconut milk in place of the half and half.
Try adding a few toasted mini marshmallows for a fun garnish.
If you don’t have Malibu rum, add regular rum and some coconut extract.

Equipment

Measuring spoons
Cocktail shaker
Two cocktail glasses

Storage

These cocktails are best fresh. I don’t recommend storing them. Luckily, the recipe only makes two cocktails at a time, so as long as you serve them as requested, there should be no cocktails left over.

What to Serve with a Malibu Butterscotch Schnapps Cocktail

Pair this cocktail with your favorite sweet treats for a lovely adult dessert treat. In particular, dark or milk chocolate, white chocolate, and coconut-flavored cookies. Many other dessert really shine with this cocktail.

Tips

Crush the butterscotch finely, but don’t powder it.
If you don’t have a cocktail shaker, you can stir the cocktail in a large glass.
For the best flavor, serve your cocktails immediately after you make them.

More Cocktail Recipes

FAQ

What is a Malibu Butterscotch Schnapps Cocktail?

A Malibu Butterscotch Schnapps Cocktail is made with milk or half and half, peppermint schnapps, Malibu rum, with the rim of a glass that’s been smeared with melted white chocolate or vanilla frosting then, crushed butterscotch candy. Sounds amazing, right?

How small should I crush the butterscotch candies for this cocktail?

You want your butterscotch candies to be crushed relatively small. It should be small enough to be drinkable but not powdered.

Will regular rum work in this cocktail?

If you don’t have Malibu rum, regular rum will work. You could also add regular rum and a bit of coconut extract to achieve a similar flavor.